I'm speechless.

DocBot

Administrator
Staff member
This is kind of a part answer to docbots verbal BEATING! that he just enduced, i may need to rally my PR team and come up with some fancy pie charts to subdue him


HA! No pie charts shall harm me! (I hope you didn't take offense - as have been stated in other posts, this subject does tend to get personal and, ahem, "high spirited")
 

Nanor

Well-Known Member
How many single mothers do you know who have massively successful careers? I don't know any.

Frankly, I don't know many single mothers. I know one off the top of my head who lives in a massive house with a big ass television and had a nice car until she crashed it. She isn't getting the money from her dream career, I'l admit, but she's certainly getting it from the ex-husband.
 

PsiSoldier

Well-Known Member
silkth said:
How many single mothers do you know who have massively successful careers? I don't know any.
How many single fathers do you know who have massively successful careers? I don't know any.

Works both ways.
 

PsiSoldier

Well-Known Member
Quite alot of single fathers actually, compared to mothers. At least 7 of my old school friends lived with their father, only 2 (including me) living with their mother.
 

DocBot

Administrator
Staff member
hm, okay then. The point I was trying to make is that nine out of ten single parents are women. Your old school was a statistical anomaly, and doesn't count :P
 

Silk

Well-Known Member
Frankly, I don't know many single mothers. I know one off the top of my head who lives in a massive house with a big ass television and had a nice car until she crashed it. She isn't getting the money from her dream career, I'l admit, but she's certainly getting it from the ex-husband.

You think the guy has to pay that much? Wrooong. I can't quote exact figures but the last single mum I knew got peanuts from the guy who decided to run off.

Majority of that cash is coming from goverment, i.e. tax payers.

Everyone's different but I bet most people in that situation would be out there working rather than spending every minute of every day stuck in the house raising a child.
 

Silk

Well-Known Member
How many single fathers do you know who have massively successful careers? I don't know any.

Works both ways.

*shrugs* Yes it does. Call it single parent then for I care.

However - it is more likely to be a woman, being as she grows the child in her belly and has no easy way out.
 

Silk

Well-Known Member
On the subject of child rearing after birth:

I'd completely agree that, prior to child birth, a woman is in a situation where they either carry their baby to term or abort and that this is a situation that she and only she can have final say in as, fundamentally, she is directly linked to the baby.

However, after child birth, this fundamental physical connection has been severed. At that point, it is over to child rearing, which there are many different models for. Some American Indians share (shared?) mothering responsibilities among the females of their tribe such that a single mother isn't solely responsible. In some families, the father actually takes the brunt of the child rearing, leaving the mother to work (my uncle was that way). The point, there, is that choices return to both parents. Sure, there's a huge consideration about what is to be done to ensure the baby's wellbeing and development, but it isn't as one-sided as you suggest.

(Unless I'm also missing your point?)

Well you are a lil bit. I was talking about the situation where the guy either ran off, or there was never a relationship in the first place (some drunken one night stand).

Assuming she can't abort..

The options after childbirth for the mother aren't in any way guaranteed to give her what she wants or needs. I would need to double check but I'm pretty sure, for example, she can't turn around to the nurse and say "I don't want to be a mother, please find other parents to adopt this child".

She can elect to put it up for adoption but the process isn't instant or guaranteed. All the other options you mentioned are probably not available to her either (lets assume her family have disowned her, and the father isn't around).

More likely than not she will have to be a mother, regardless of what she wanted. So in saying "abortion is wrong" not only have we told her what to do with her body, but we have told her what to do with her life, her future.

Does this not seem to be a breach of basic human rights?
 

Nanor

Well-Known Member
I have, honestly, never heard of anyone not allowed to put their child up for adoption. Genuinely. Can I get some figures regarding not being allowed to put your child up for adoption or something so we're on the same level?
 

Silk

Well-Known Member
I have, honestly, never heard of anyone not allowed to put their child up for adoption. Genuinely. Can I get some figures regarding not being allowed to put your child up for adoption or something so we're on the same level?

"She can elect to put it up for adoption but the process isn't instant or guaranteed. "

You'd have to look up the facts but I'm pretty sure e.g. if the child has some disability you can't put it up for adoption.

And the process can take some time. What if there are no people who want to adopt? Hence, it isn't guaranteed.
 

Nanor

Well-Known Member
Ah, yes. Even still, I've never heard of this happening. Though, to be honest, I don't know of many people who put their child up for adoption.
 

Traxata

Junior Administrator
I know a few people who have adopted other kids, but none that I can think of who have put them up for adoption.
 

PsiSoldier

Well-Known Member
Well you are a lil bit. I was talking about the situation where the guy either ran off, or there was never a relationship in the first place (some drunken one night stand).

So, don't have kids unless in a stable relationship then. That sounds sensible to me.
 

DocBot

Administrator
Staff member
So, don't have kids unless in a stable relationship then. That sounds sensible to me.

er, yes? This is abortion we're discussing? As a means to not have kids if you, for example, happen to not be in a stable relationship?
 

Gopha

In Cryo Sleep
I thought this was about Adoption, not abortion. Children CAN be taken away from homes if the homes are not deemed suitable ie mother or father keeps having different partners who are abusive etc. So even if they couldnt have a child put up for adoption, they could treat it really poorly then have it taken into care.
 
Top